First of all, hello - I usually post in the road, SS/FG, or nutrition forum but am finally in a position to use bikes for function; how novel!

Anyways, I'm selling my fixed gear to get something that's a better all-round functional ride. This will be primarily a commuter and I'm settled on the functionality of a cyclocross frame, or at least a frame set up for canti brakes, rack capabilities, and fender clearance. I also like the idea of having a bike with a road drivetrain that can go on dirt roads and light singletrack and even load up for a ride-camp-ride weekend.

I'm torn between a lower end Scattante aluminum frame that will be a great commuter and excellent #2 road bike, or something nicer and heavier like a Handsome Devil or Surly that can be configured any number of ways, can tour, but not quite the geo or weight I'm used to. Thus, I turn to those who have been in the commuting business for a while - what do you find to hit the sweet spot between commuter beast, backup road bike, and light tourist?

I have a spare low end Shimano groupset (2200 or 2300) and cheap wheels to throw on for now, along with bars, stem, seatpost, and saddle. I'll want to upgrade wheels, switch to a compact double and 105 or Apex/Rival level eventually. I figure I can get $450 for my fixed gear and here's what I'm looking at:

Scattante XRL Cyclocross ($225, leaving $225 for upgrades):


Handsome Devil ($420ish for frame):


Surly Cross Check ($380, leaving $70 for upgrades):


I know that the Scattante will have a much different functionality than the Handsome or Surly, but I still am trying to figure what style of ride will be the most practical...

THANKS IN ADVANCE FOR YOUR INPUT!