I'm with Clifton on this one- when it comes to road tires- I look for the label on the side that says "Pasela TG". I even had my own gatorskin phase.

It's always a push and pull between feel, off pavement traction, durability, flat protection, and price. The Paselas nail it. I'm certain there's probably a tire out there that beats it, but it will certainly cost more.

I've tried plenty of cheaper tires, and nothing comes close.