Thread: Ask Scrod
View Single Post
Old 04-18-12 | 08:41 PM
  #3416  
Santaria's Avatar
Santaria
Senior Member
 
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 2,174
Likes: 0
From: Brownsville, TX

Bikes: Surly CC

Originally Posted by justfitme
Not sure anymore..so you are saying that knocking can't come out from BB.. The starnge thing I never heard the sound like this from any multi speed bike but it is a second SS I hear it from (GTB and now this one).. I was thinking about BB in both cases... I do not know. ...have to admit

I would hold on this .. I'm thinking now it may be that old Delta cleat on old Look pedal I pulled from my wife's bike few days ago ...but she never complained..but it does not mean anything..
A creaking or tinging (I guess it could technically sound like a knocking) could come out of a bottom bracket shell, but I'm assuming you've properly installed your bracket and cups, everything is properly tensioned and greased. In some older frames where they used locktite, I've heard of a creaking, but not a knocking. Most modern **** out there has pretty good bearings, unless its crappier than a '52, even then if its greased and packed right, shouldn't be getting a pop or ting out of it - let alone a knocking sound.

/notscrod
Santaria is offline