Originally Posted by
vsanthos
Thanks for the quick feedback. I've just been thinking a lot lately that I'd be happier if I had an indexed shifting system. But, I have no basis of comparison so it's just my own interpretation. I've also thought of how much easier a single speed would be for my local commuting (longest ride is 3-4 miles to work). But, I fear that my area is too hilly for my fat ass not to be able to downshift.
One possiblity for your commute is an internal hub gear, such as a Nexus or Alfine. You get the simplicity of just one chainring and cog, with the gears when you need them. They are heavier than derailleur systems, and you need to stop pedalling for a second or two while you shift, but on the plus side you can shift while stopped at an intersection (useful in traffic). They are also a little more weather-proof as there is less exposed to the outside.