CycleCraft is a good shop but my experience is the level of service can be hit or miss depending on how busy they are. If you know someone there by name you might want to call ahead and let them know you're coming.
As an aside, I've found Marty's and High Gear to offer consistently great service.
As I understand it, there's only one guy at CycleCraft that does the fittings - Mike, I think his name is - and it's by appointment only. I had to wait a week and half to get on his calendar!
I think I have his attention for an hour, busy or not.
Marty's sounds really familiar. Is that the one in Morristown? I used to work in Whippany, and I think I've been in there.