Originally Posted by
therhodeo
Whether BMI works or not its pretty obvious if you're ever out in public that lots of people are fat. And lots of people who say they're "muscular" and that BMI doesn't apply to them are fat too.
Almost all of them. BMI works on populations precisely because most people are not heavily-muscled athletes. Most cyclists aren't, either. The "BMI doesn't work" brigade is overwhelmingly peopled by the fat.