Originally Posted by
staehpj1
Buy the one that you find more comfortable. For me that would definitely not be the Brooks, but that is me. I'd advise a firm saddle with no gel and not much padding. I guess I am lucky because I have found the original saddles that came with my bikes to all be something that I could adjust to and use even on multi month tours. If buying new I pick a racing saddle.
But I cant do that, because in this country I'm not able to test either of the saddles before buying. I'm also concerned that although one saddle might be comfortable, that I might unknowingly damage my sexual health by using it. So while I know that the brooks is comfortable from having owned one in the past, I'm not sure I entirely trust it with perenial pressure.
That Selle Anatomica is tempting, but $40 shipping is pretty steep.