Comfort on the Selle Anatomicas apparently is amazing... right out of the package is ready to go and really comfortable! Durability has been an issue, however. I've read several reports about the S.A. suffering from too much sagging over time. Many people report tightening the leather but after 5,000 miles or so the saddles are toasted needing full replacement. It surely gets pricey if you're doing long distance riding and have to change the saddle up to twice a year. They have a new 2012 version that addresses this particular issue with sturdier leather. Too early to tell as it still being tested by riders.

Southpawboston: Curious to know if you've made a decision or narrowed down your choices.