Wow, thank you all so much for the detailed responses! I actually rummaged around and found a pair of pedals with toe clips that keep my feet just snug enough while letting me pull my feet out quickly if necessary. If that doesn't work out, I may give PowerGrips a shot! Clipless would probably be ideal for my kind of riding, but staying on budget is a priority.
Originally Posted by
xenologer
I use large/deep toeclips on wide mks touring pedals, modified diagonal strap routing so they behave like powergrips. Secure enough that feet don't leave pedals on upstroke, yet easy to get out of in a hurry, lots of support too with those wide platforms...
Could you take a quick picture of this setup? I'm trying to imagine how you'd route the straps diagonally.