I'm a Clyde that rides a Romin Pro. I think saddle recommendations are -nearly- worthless because people vary so dramatically in what they need. One persons poison is another persons perfect. A thick cushion like that may be comfortable for 10 miles but as your butt gets broken in and your muscles get used to having your (my) fat a$$ sit on them, the added foam becomes an irritation. You sink into it and it causes chafing and rubbing where you don't want it. Thick padded seats are good to start with because most people, particularly clydes, simply can't be comfortable on a thin, harder seat but be aware that you'll soon enough need to get a thinner, then another thinner and another still thinner seat if you continue cycling and lose weight and move your mileage to where 30mi days are common, be aware that your seat type will change. That's why I have about 6 seats that represent stages of my weight loss (roughly 60lb at this point) and fitness gain. Hopefully that's a typical trend for clydes on bikes. Personally I see no reason for a 165lb person to use such a cushy saddle unless all you ever want to do is a 10mi ride at a comfy pace. Nothing wrong with that but a thick saddle like that will only ****** your ability/chance to improve your cycling if you don't really need the thickness. Even at 280lb I never used a thick saddle like that, but again...we are all so very different that the only solution is to try saddles out and find what works for you.