Originally Posted by
bcpetersjr
You seem to assume that I am just going to go out and buy the first thing someone recommends, that is not the case. People suggest that I change things out I am just wondering if they have specific recommendations. If I look at them and I don't like them I would not buy it but it may lead me to one that I would like. I have been looking at a bunch of saddles and it is hard to know what is good and what isn't. There are different materials and designs. I was just looking for some guidance, that's what this whole post is about.
That's just it. Most of the recommendations/suggestions that you receive will be from experience. And everyone is different. There will be point and counter point on any bike, route selection, gear, article of clothing, frame material, cargo management, drive train set up... saddles are generally one of those items that takes time to find one that fits and is comfortable.
Lots of people will swear by a certain Brooks saddle, yet there will be a few who- though not really trash talking- will point out that model isn't for everyone, because they tried it out for themselves and found it lacking somehow.
You yourself pointed out that you find the saddle uncomfortable. The best way to minimize the chances of replicating that with another saddle is to find one that comes closest to lining up with your sit bones- and you won't know what size you need until you measure them.