I rode all my bikes comfortably until I bought a road bike with a selle san marcos saddle I tried to ride it for around six months thinking it would break in. It never got comfortable, got another saddle and never looked back. I would say try a different saddle, it doesn't need to be a brooks just one you can ride in comfort. Some bike shops will let you demo them for a minimal cost, mine charges $25 to try as many as I like then if I buy one that money goes to the purchase. Then you can sell you current one to offset the cost.