Originally posted by JohnnyFausto
On this aluminum aspect, I too was leary to buy an aluminum framed bicycle just because of all the negative press they receive, even though I had never ridden one (roadbike alum.) I ended up buying a 2001 Bianchi SL Daytona and am very pleased with my choice. It doesn't feel overly harsh to me, sprints and climbs very well, is equiped with Campy Daytona drivetrain that has worked so far just perfect (6 months) This was my first road bike, and just like you I have been an avid mt. biker for a long time, and I know how overwelming it can be when you start to experience the road bike world!
Are you referring to ride quality or durability in aluminum frames?
Like pokey said, (Dear Lord, I'm agreeing with pokey), it mostly depends on the rider you ask. Some don't like the way a typical aluminum bike rides. I for one do. Too many factors to really give you an answer to the question which one is best, though. Like has been mentioned, get to know a roadie or two at your local shop, get a bike that fits you right, and go from there. Your own experience over the years is the best teacher. Most of it really is preference; shifters, frame materials, etc.