I have the Commuter 1 at my campus, and its all I need. It doesn't have the best components but its gets the job done. The rack and fenders make it definitely commuter ready hints the name. The tires aren't really good but those are easily replaceable. Just take care of it and it will last a while. Oh and don't get to caught up in what material the bike is. These guys just like to argue for the fun of it. Good luck at school.