The NiteRider is the only one I have experience with, and it is very, very good. The others in the comparison are probably good also, but I haven't used them. The lumia line of lights are the next generation of the old MiNewt Cordless series which, viewing from a cost to quality perspective, are legendary. I still use the MiNewt 600 Cordless and it is great, although it's no match for my 1500 Race flamethrower on my bar.