Originally Posted by
himespau
Brooks, you'll either love them and only them for the rest of your life or you'll learn they're not for you and never try leather again. Actually, the nice thing about brooks is lightly used sell for almost as much as new.
To the OP - the thing with Brooks, and other leather saddles, is that they are quite hard at first. Leather saddles have a break in period until it starts to form to your ass (sit bones). My first time on a Brooks was quite painful and left saddle sores. After about 10 rides, it really started to feel good - kinda like breaking in a baseball glove. They also require more care to the leather, but the payoff is worth it.
However, keep in mind that saddle recommendations are to be taken lightly. If we all had the same butts, saddle choices/recommendations would be easy. What works for one might be terrible for another. Currently, I am enjoying a Selle Italia Turbo 80's... but again, that is what works for me and might not for you.