Originally Posted by
tar wheels
My commuter is a 3-speed. I have a short commute, and it is relatively flat save for one small (but steep) hill on the way back. I've never had a single problem.
I've got one of these:
http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/...ord_deluxe.htm
I've made several mods (quill, stem, bars, etc), but I would have done that with any traditional 3-speed. For me, it was a great value and rides smoothly and quietly. I'm no expert on gearing, but I think that you will be able to find a balance with a 3-speed that meets your needs.
Hey! I have the same bike but removed the fenders. The Windsor has fairly low second gear (54 inch) and it's perfect. However, riding long distance with even a low gear like that can wear you out. I find wishing for a 52 or 50 inch gear during the end of the ride.