Originally Posted by
pgjackson
Is the OP planning on being a competitive racer? If not then the handling aspects of various frame sizes is not important. Seriously, 3/4 of an inch doesn't make that much difference.
I can't abide this kind of nonsense - that proper handling is only important to racers. Slot that in with light weight, nice components, etc. It's baloney. If you are riding a road bike, proper handling is hugely important. Even if you aren't pushing the limits. A bicycle that handles right is more pleasant to ride, and safer. You don't need to be a racer to enjoy those benefits.
I've ridden road bikes that weren't optimally set up. Sure, it can be tolerated, and you might not know what you're missing. But you're still missing something. When I finally got on a bike that fitted and handled right, it was a revelation, and I wouldn't go back by choice.