Neither are particularly good for carrying panniers, particularly if your feet are not tiny. If carrying panniers is a priority, I would look for something with longer chainstays. You will have more heal clearance as well as more stability. My Surly Cross Check has similar geometry. I don't find it suitable for carrying panniers at all. Front becomes too light (unless I keep a very aggressive position) & I need smaller, specifically shaped panniers to keep my heels from striking the bags.