Everyone is different. But Brooks saddles are well liked by most people who try them. I think some must tolerate the 'break in' period just to convince themselves they spent their $150 bucks wisely, then when it finally does break in they legitimately love them.

The reason I don't have one is because I am too lazy to maintain the parts of my bike that make it run, and I believe that getting a brooks saddle wet or muddy or leaving it outside for the winter will adversely affect it.

The other thing you need to consider for a commuter saddle is theft - can you ensure your saddle will never be stolen ('security' bolts, cables and locks, very low theft area, parked in a secure location), and if it is stolen, will you have to choose between buying a new one and buying food?