Check out the Selle Italia Flite series. I found them to be immediately comfortable. Also keep in mind that since you are coming off a long break from cycling, even a decent saddle is going to require that your rear end get broken in along with it. I started riding a Selle Italia SLR after a year off the bike due to deployment overseas and it was pure torture at first. The Flite was my solution. After getting back on the SLR, and after giving it a couple hundred miles, I am totally comfortable on it and love it.