Originally Posted by
rpenmanparker
No argument about your observations, but don't you really mean that is how those saddles work for you. The Pro is more comfortable for you. The cutout tends to pinch your bottom. It is impossible to recommend for or against any saddle for any person except yourself.
Robert
Saddle fit has always been a personal affair. That said, to avoid the cut-out pinching effect, the edge of the hole must be very soft and flexible. But a soft surrounding can cause your bottom to sink after a long ride, resulting in discomfort. Additionally, a cut-out that's large enough to relieve pain will most likely compromise the structural integrity of the saddle. The saddle may only last a few thousand miles before hitting the trash. This is why some older well-worn leather saddles are so highly prized. Once the saddle has molded itself to your shape, there is little pressure points, except for the sit-bone areas.