Originally Posted by
FBinNY
Have it your way. I don't care. But arguing about the specific cause, doesn't change the simple fact that nipple failure happens when spoke are too short.
I said in my first response that I wasn't trying to convince you, just posting what I knew. This is a forum, you post your opinion, others post theirs and readers can choose what to believe.
As far as I'm concerned this thread has achieved dead horse status. But anyone interested can find more
here. Plenty of links to work your way through. Happy hunting.
Again, poor metallurlogy could be the root cause of the nipple failure. You have not provide any scientific data to support your claim. Your assertion is based on data taken 40 years ago on spokes that may be vastly inferior to modern stuffs from DT and other top tier manufacturers.