No. This cant be a good deal. An 8 year older bike than you are currently riding? An aluminum, 8 year older bike than you are currently riding? Is this Cannondale 9 speed or 10 speed D/A? I cant remember when 10 speed came out.
What is so wrong with Carbon Fiber that you need to "get away" from it?
Have you tried a different set of wheels to see if it...unsmooshifies your fuji when you really put the pedals down?

Ultimately its your bike, trade if you want to but I can see no logic in this trade.