Originally Posted by
Sean Gordon
I've used a Brooks Swift Ti and a B17 that I cut down to mimic a swallow. They broke in awesome and worked for about six months. I used snow-seal (beeswax based) to treat them, but I destroyed both fairly quickly. Leather saddles are for recreational, occasional high mileage use, like on a bike tour. They won't hold up to a racer's training regimen, being bathed in salt sweat, rain, road salt, etc. and then ridden hard the next day.
Incorrect.
Just because YOU destroyed your Brooks saddles doesn't mean that if they are treated properly they won't hold up to a variety of conditions.
If they'll hold up for a randonneur, they'll hold up for a racer.