The price on that Surly looks a little high, and I don't think that BD bike is a fantastic deal. I've seen full Ultegra bikes on BD for $900.

I'd recommend waiting for good deal to come along on craiglist. For $100-200 you can buy a lot of bike if you have the patience to wait for the right deal.

If you don't want to take the time to shop used, I get it. Hit some local shops and ask if they have any 2012 leftovers. Over the last month I've seen some ridiculous deals on some really good new 2012's.

Keep your local shops in mind for used bikes too. Most take trades, and sometimes you can get pretty good deals.