Old 07-24-13 | 10:51 PM
  #37  
prathmann
Senior Member
 
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 7,239
Likes: 8
From: Bay Area, Calif.
Originally Posted by paulypro
Thank you for the advice, but respectfully, I still disagree. I'm just saying regardless if some lobbyists decided to paint cryptic bike symbols on roadways 11 feet out or not, that I'd feel like a dick holding up traffic if there's space for me to move aside, such as a long break in parked cars, decent shoulder roadspace etc. I find myself on sharrow marked bike routes daily and almost always end up well to the right of them, aside from the times when it's necessary to take up that lateral space.
...
Seems like there are a few things you're forgetting.
1) Lobbyists aren't often found painting road markings on streets. The SLM symbol was adopted only after considerable study by traffic engineers including experimental placement in a number of trial locations where the effects on safety, traffic flow, and public acceptance could be studied. The required placement out in the traffic lane was found to be the optimum location so unless you've done an equivalent amount of study on your contrary preferred lane position you might want to reconsider.

2) In the OP's video it's quite clear that in fact there was no impediment to other traffic since there was a second lane available and only occasionally did a motor vehicle use it to pass the OP. If there had been a line of traffic forming behind the OP there would have been a steady stream of vehicles passing him in the lane to the left. The video doesn't show what was behind the OP, but I'd expect that the only time anyone would have followed him would have been if they planned to make a right turn - in which case following the cyclist is far preferable to just barely passing him and then cutting him off with a right hook.

3) Sharrows are not just placed randomly on assorted streets but instead there are specific guidelines. When those guidelines are followed sharrows are placed where they function as depicted in the OP's video - on streets where the right-hand lane is too narrow for cyclists to safely be in it alongside motor vehicles that also remain in that lane and where traffic flow and safety will be best if cyclists position themselves at about the sharrow distance from the curb.
prathmann is offline  
Reply