Thanks for the tips, everyone. I will look into the suggestions and see if I can find a solution.

But to be concise, the GPS in my phone is off (by roughly 35 feet, at least in my home, this is a NEW inaccuracy). So it's my phone not strava directly. Will try reset trick and if nothing else works I will consider the SNAP suggestion.

Of course my iPhone 4 is getting a little old so the ultimate solution may be to upgrade to an iPhone 5, but I figured it's best to wait until the 5s comes out in a few weeks and the price on the 5 will drop like a stone.