The Sedona lives out at my parents' house, it's too nice a bike to live outdoors in Manhattan. Bike theft (even with a NY Kryptonite lock) is not uncommon, and I'd rather not be riding around on it here.

Plus, I need something to ride when I go home and visit my dad. I'm probably going to fix up the Fuji and either keep it as a guest bike or donate it.

By 'bike size', do you mean BB to top tube, or what? And by inseam, you mean foot to crotch? I don't believe the bike is completely the wrong size, but I could be wrong.

Top tube size is 23", seat tube and downtube are 24". (measuring from the outside of the BB). My inseam (heel to crotch) is 30". I'm 5'10, 155lb.