Originally Posted by
KonAaron Snake
Honestly - I think it's trends and marketing; rando is hot now. There are plenty of bikes that make great all arounders and the slight variations determine what is most ideal, but most are plenty suited to 95% + of what they'll be up against. Cyclocross, 80s style sports tourers, XO-1s, converted MTB platforms, full tourers built up like sports tourers...you name it.
I'll agree that it's all trends and marketing. However, I'll have to disagree that many of the bikes being touted as "all around" commuters are actually useful as commuters. They can be made to work...I have a cyclocross that I use for commuting, among others...but I've never understood the reluctance of people to use bikes that are purpose built for carrying loads on a stable platform. One would think that a bike designed to carry 50 or 60 lb for years on end would appeal to people who carry more to work than I carry for a month long tour. But touring bikes are almost never suggested as a commuting platform.