Originally Posted by
keyven
. . . . The S-bag sounded like it would fit me nicely with the shape but multiple reviews bemoaned the fact that it is somewhat small. . . .
I have an old S-bag and it's surprisingly big for its "look" due to the 6 side pockets - especially the back pocket and the bottle pocket. Much more handy access to your stuff than a back pack. The front zip on the black flap make it so easy to constantly reach for your tourist map while traveling. I leave my rain jacket permantly on the flap compartment during the wet season. For colder season, I tuck my jacket under the flap.
When riding, I tuck the shoulder strap safely under the flap. Not sure how a backpack straps can safely tucked away.
Carradice " Original Cadet Saddlebag " is my favorite - not too big and waterproof . I can carry my 6-Pack beer easy and more
. Occasionally I hang a medium dry sac on its side when the saddle bag is too full.