Originally Posted by
cyccommute
You can solve one problem with the extenders but created others that are far worse. One of the reasons that touring bikes have such long chainstays is to keep the panniers out of the way of your feet and keep much of the rear load either centered over the rear axle or slightly in front of it. Cantilevering a load beyond the rear axle with the rack extenders puts the load behind the rear axle and can lead to handling issues on many bikes. It also leads to a lightening of the front end. The tail starts to wag the dog, so to speak. This effect is particularly noticeable on high speed downhills where the front end of the bike can wobble. High speed and wobble is not a good thing!
Couldn't agree more with everything you state, but........... there are many fine touring bikes with 445mm chainstays and less that many people have successfully toured with. I doubt that an additional 2-3% chainstay length is more important than where you place your panniers and how they're packed as to stability. Bottom line, probably not a deal breaker for me or most.