Originally Posted by
rydabent
So------------what do members here believe the "proper and needed" number of gears should be?
The total "number of gears" isn't the issue, the Range of gearing is.
The answer is both "it depends" and "it changes".
A cyclist requires a Low range "bottom" gear that allows climbing the worst grade they will encounter comfortably and a High range "top" for bombing down the backside w/o the "hamster-in-cage effect". Cram as many cogs on in between as budget and aesthetics allow for efficiency.
Required ranges will change w/ terrain, weather conditions, load, distance and fitness.
Modern cassettes are easy to change and relatively inexpensive. Swap out a straight block "flatland set" or a medium range "hilly" cassette to a wide range "mountain" as conditions require.
Set-up your machine w/ the chainrings (one, two or three), derail type and shifters that works with your Widest Range, swap cassettes as required and proceed.
-Bandera