I have an opposite opinion. Get the Roam. Yes, those front suspension forks do work when you want them, and the lock outs do work when you don't.

Plus, the Roam will let you fit bigger tires, should you desire them. And more room for fenders, if you want them.

You almost always get more bang for your buck with Giant.

The Roam is a really nice utility bike, much like my Crosstrail, which I dearly love.

MHO