My B 17 doesn't make any noise at all. When it rains, I simply cover the saddle with the cheap plastic bag I always carry under the saddle , between the rails. I like mine. I've tried the Selle Anatomica , with less than satisfactory results YMMV. If I try something other than a brooks ( not very likely ) it would be the Selle SMP, I've heard a lot of good regarding it's comfort.