My B17 makes no noise after 2 years. Quite happy with it. Plan on doing some longer rides this summer and am happy to have it.

It also makes my Trek 7.2 FX look a bit classier!

I also recall reading a story about a cyclist who purchased his Brooks saddle just prior to WWII and used it as long as he was able. So let's assume he used it for 50 years. What other saddle could you use that long? Perhaps Brooks is really the cheapest way to go for the long haul!