Velo-orange has leather bar tape for $75, elkhide bar wraps you sew on, and Tressostar cloth tape for $5
Handlebar Tape, Grips, Accessories - Accessories
Cinelli cork tape for $12 and Tressostar cloth tape for $4
Lickbike.com | Product Index - Handlebar Tape/Grips
The LBS always has a big supplyof Fi'zik and that's what I normally use. I've also used the cloth tape and it looks good.
Plastic bar tape
http://chickscyclingclub.com/plastic-handlebar-tape/
Velox Plastilac tape NOS
http://www.budgetbicyclectr.com/velo...handlebar-tape
Velox Guidoline Champion NOS cloth tape
http://budgetbicyclectr.com/velox-gu...qt9auhaacce113