Yeah I'm definitely thinking quill too. BUT I'm having a hard time finding them online. I know it needs to be 1", but I'm not sure how tall. I need to get my bike back from the shop so I can measure the current old stem on it.
I'm also not sure about how much reach forward I want on it. Thinking of keeping it shorter - around 60-80mm (I'm only 5'5") - my current stem on my Cross-Check is 80mm.

I've found relatively few on amazon and nashbar. it needs to be silver so it matches the rest of the parts of the bike. with a 26 clamp.

I know people will say Ebay, but I want to buy it from an actual store not worry about some dude shipping it and it taking 14 days to show up.

any ideas?