Which one you choose?

2nd hand for both bikes, both are 300$. Both look pretty new in picture.
Both AL frame & carbon fork, both are 52cm

Motobecane > giant in theses
-better components (tiagra front double, 105 rear derailleur) ( giant has 2300)

Giant > Motobecane
-the name
-thinner tires


Please help I'm too noob to make the decision

Specs are as follow
Motobecane USA | Cyclocross Bicycles | Track Bicycles | Cross Bicycles

2008 Giant OCR 3 - BikePedia