Originally Posted by
Wanderer
They look the same on paper, except for the benefit of the Giant fork. Componentry is almost identical.
If they ride the same to you, buy the one you fall in love with. I agree with you, I like the looks of the Giant, and it will ride better. On top of that, it's cheaper.
I have definitely been leaning towards the Giant. One of my concerns in regard to the Componentry is the shifters. The Giant has Tourney while the Trek has Altus. Is that a big deal?