Originally Posted by
acceleration
One of the big differences I see between the Escape 3 and 2 besides the fork, is that the 2 is a 8 speed while the 3 speed is a 7 speed. I know more speeds is optimal, but is the difference really significant? Does it depend on where you plan to ride?
The number of speeds won't be that significant.
The Giant 3 actually has the better granny gear for big hills and the Giant 2 has better gearing for gaining pace on a downhill path.
You should try riding both if you can, because looking at spec sheets is one thing, but nothing will beat the actual riding experience of a test ride.
Will the crank on one of the bikes feel better than the other? Feel like you are more able to efficiently transfer force via your peddling?
Does steering with a handlebar that is 31.8mm wide in the middle feel any different to one that is 25.4mm wide?
Does the better derailleur of the Giant 3 and different shifters, give you a better shifting experience or does it feel the same?
On paper, there shouldn't be that big a difference between each bike.