I ordered this one last night

I figured I would give it a shot. I never thought about going to a local bike shop and asking for any they had taken off of a bike they sold. I have just ridden the saddle that was on my bikes. I have not had a problem with at least 4 different saddles.

the saddle that broke was on my MOtobecane fantom FX I am surprised it lasted and was for the most part comfortable because it looked cheap.