Originally Posted by
cpf_carrot
I have a good lighting system already.
As for the MTB, besides the general dislike for mountain geometry on road I am concerned about the seals on the front suspension getting messed up by salt, etc from winter grime. Is that not a valid concern? I read that they can get damaged from winter use.
Fair enough. A vintage mountain bike with a rigid fork makes a great commuter and they can be found even in NYC well within your price range. They handle pretty darn well so I'm skeptical that the problem is mountain bike geometry.
The real point is whether you want drops or not. I love drops but prefer flat bars for commuting in the winter. YMMV.