Originally Posted by
Lazyass
Originally Posted by
Lazyass
One time only? I assume you completely removed the pin from the link? You should push it out just far enough to separate the links. Then push it back in to reassemble the chain.
Can we vote to change your user name to "smart***"?

Don't you think that someone who has been on C&V for 9 years and has 8000+ post knows a little something about chain replacement?
Shimano literature insists that the entire pin be replaced each time the chain is "broken" for service, etc. I couldn't find this document, but I believe we all trust
Park Tool for expert guidance. Scroll down a bit until you come to the Shimano chain section.
The relevant section is quoted below:
Procedure for Shimano® Chain
Some chains, including Shimano®, use chain rivets which are peened. This creates a "mushroom" effect at the ends of the rivets, which adds to the strength of the chain side plates. When a rivet is pressed even partially out, this peening is sheered off on the side pressed by the chain tool. If this rivet were reused, it would create a weak link at that rivet. In the image below, a Shimano® rivet is shown in an optical comparator, which magnifies the rivet. The original peening is seen at the bottom of the rivet. The top of rivet has the peening sheered off. This top section was pushed through the outer chain plate.

Shimano® chains use a special connecting rivet when the chain is installed new or when one is removed and re-installed. This connecting rivet has special flaring that is guided in by a long tapered pilot. The pilot is then broken off before riding. Only Shimano® brand chains should use the Shimano® connecting rivet.

The 7 and 8 speed chains use a black connecting rivet. The narrower 9-speed chain uses a silver-colored connecting rivet. The Shimano ® CN-7800 chain for 10-speeds uses a silver colored rivet with an extra-machined line for identification on the pilot. The Shimano ® CN-7801 chain for 10-speed sprockets uses a connecting rivet with three machined identification lines. The 10-speed chain rivets are not interchangeable.
Hopefully this helps you understand a bit more of what some of us are talking about.