Thanks guys for all the saddle suggestions. I will look into them and see which one fits my needs/budget the best. This isn't a grail bike and I know this model isn't worth much, especially a well-used one. But I've had it since my freshman year of college and would just like to put her back into shape. Over the years I've had a few parts repaired or replaced and now I just want to get it back to stock as much as possible (maybe with the exception of the saddle).