Originally Posted by
peppep
1) We're wanting to keep the cost under $400.
2) (and maybe at least a front hand-break?). Also, she's 5'8", so any that are tiny will not do
I disagree on internal versus external gears on a new bike. I prefer external. The entire drive train can be completely replaced very easily, and cheaply, even by a rookie.
If the gearing isn't quite right you can change it for under $20 (plus a simple tool or cheap labor). If an IGH screws up you have to send the wheel off or take it to an LBS and prepare to bend over.
Some of the bikes you list don't meet the $400 limit.
GET HANDBRAKES, at least a front.
I prefer a 3 piece crank.
This bike also has pedal forward technology, which is nice. It also is available in adult colors.