I do agree that it seems a little odd. I try to do as much work myself, but this was outside my ability. This was my first time going to this guy, on the recommendation of a buddy.

It wasn't play in the headset, the fork area actually was flexing before he took it off. He did overhaul the headset before we started the fork discussions, so I think that is in good shape. The new one is already on, but I can't get over there to see anything until Monday. So, my eternal optimism is hoping that this was actually two issues where I thought it was just one. I'll definitely be sceptical when I talk to him. My money tree didn't produce a very big crop this summer, so I certainly dont want to buy something I dont need.

That said, because of what I learned with the missing spacer, I do think that the head tube issue is likely legit. My only thought on it I wonder if I have him pull the headset and grease the tube and then reinstal it, would that help with the creaking?

Thoughts?