There's not many people that don't like the Spoon. Universal has over 25 reviews. Of course it didn't work for a few, no saddle is going to work for everyone, but it's got a 4+ rating.

I've had one for most of this season and it's still on the bike. I use it around town, usually around ten miles and wear anything that I want with it. Not a lot of time in jeans though, Georgia summers and jeans don't mesh well.