Originally Posted by
superslomo
This would be a new bike to get myself something nicer than what I currently have, not just to get another bike for comparatively practical purposes. The only practical element is that I'd have my current bike to put/keep fenders on, throw a rack onto it, and keep cross or studded tires on as needed, as it'll fit them. The new bike would be on the lighter side, if possible. I'm not taking a step backwards through history to go 3x8, maybe it's vanity or whatever, but it just seems like the direction I don't want to go in... I want to get the last best triple I can lay my hands on if I'm going to do this, otherwise I can just get a compact like everyone seems to tell me is so much more sensible.
The area around the Hudson river (which is where the OP lives) has some of the finest hills on the east coast. Lots of beautiful areas to ride (Harriman, the gunks, the catskills, and places in between) but the hills there are some tough. I'd go with a triple if I lived there.
If I wanted the best triple available, I'd probably get the sugino XD600. I prefer 110/74 bcd crank arms over the shimano design (130/74) but YMMV.