Hey, thought I'd provide the final on this question. I found a Salsa Casseroll on Craigslist, gave it a test ride and realized it was perfect. Just the right responsiveness, lighter and better handling, yet still nice and stable. I bought it, returned the Novara (love REI), and haven't looked back.

Funny end to the story: I just get an email from the person who sold me the bike. He wants to buy it back at cost plus a $400 premium. First time I've seen seller's remorse.

This Casseroll is a sweet bike. Really a pleasure to ride.